External DNS in Kubernetes: Pros, Cons, and Critical Best Practices

What Is External DNS? 

External DNS refers to an architecture where Domain Name System (DNS) records are managed outside of an internal network, typically through cloud-based or hosted DNS service providers. This setup allows for easier control, scalability, and integration with external services. External DNS is particularly relevant for organizations using Kubernetes to manage their applications, as it provides a way to manage DNS records automatically based on the Kubernetes resources.

By leveraging External DNS, organizations can ensure that their services are reachable via user-friendly domain names instead of bare IP addresses. Managed DNS services also offer capabilities such as geo-routing and DDoS protection, which are important for maintaining high availability and security.

This is part of a series of articles about Kubernetes management.

How External DNS Works in Kubernetes

External DNS operates by dynamically updating DNS records based on the state of your Kubernetes resources. When a new service is deployed in a Kubernetes cluster, External DNS automatically creates or updates the corresponding DNS records. This automation is achieved through a synchronization process that monitors Kubernetes resources such as Services and Ingresses, translating their statuses into DNS updates.

The general process is as follows:

1. Service discovery: External DNS continuously watches for changes in Kubernetes resources. When a new Service or Ingress is created, it detects these changes in near real-time.
2. DNS record management: Based on predefined rules and configurations, External DNS determines the appropriate DNS records that need to be created or updated. It supports various DNS record types like A, CNAME, and TXT.
3. Interaction with DNS providers: External DNS interacts with cloud-based or hosted DNS providers through their APIs. This interaction involves creating, updating, or deleting DNS records to reflect the current state of the Kubernetes resources.
4. Propagation: Once the DNS records are updated, these changes propagate through the DNS hierarchy, making the new or updated services available under user-friendly domain names. This process can take a few seconds to several minutes, depending on the Time-To-Live (TTL) values configured.

What Is the external-dns utility?

Kubernetes external-dns is an open-source tool specifically designed to manage DNS records for Kubernetes clusters automatically. This tool watches for changes in Kubernetes resources such as Services and Ingresses and updates DNS records to reflect those changes. 

external-dns supports multiple DNS providers including AWS Route 53, Google Cloud DNS, and Azure DNS. It is highly configurable, allowing you to specify rules for DNS record creation, update intervals, and more.

You can get external-dns from the official GitHub repo.

Examples of External DNS Tools 

Here are several cloud-based external DNS tools you can integrate with your Kubernetes environment.

Amazon Route 53

Amazon Route 53 is a scalable, highly available DNS web service provided by AWS. It integrates with Kubernetes through the external-dns tool, allowing for automatic DNS record management based on the state of Kubernetes resources. Route 53 offers a variety of features such as latency-based routing, geo-routing, health checks, and DDoS protection. 

Route 53 also supports DNS failover, which can automatically redirect traffic to healthy endpoints in case of an outage, enhancing the resilience of your infrastructure. With its global network of DNS servers, Route 53 ensures low-latency DNS resolution.

Azure DNS

Azure DNS is a high-performance, reliable DNS service offered by Microsoft Azure. It enables you to host your DNS domains and manage DNS records using the same credentials, APIs, tools, and billing as your other Azure services. 

Azure DNS integrates with Kubernetes through the external-dns tool, facilitating automated DNS record updates based on the current state of your Kubernetes resources. Azure DNS provides fast DNS responses, a global network of name servers, and robust security features, including DNSSEC support to protect against DNS spoofing attacks.

Google Cloud DNS

Google Cloud DNS is a reliable, scalable, and high-performance DNS service offered by Google Cloud Platform. It integrates with Kubernetes through the external-dns tool, allowing for automatic management of DNS records based on Kubernetes resource changes. 

Google Cloud DNS offers low-latency DNS lookups and high availability through its global network of DNS servers. It also provides features like geo-routing, which directs users to the nearest server based on their geographical location, and DNSSEC, which protects against DNS threats by ensuring the authenticity and integrity of DNS responses.

Tips from the expert

Itiel Shwartz

Co-Founder & CTO

Itiel is the CTO and co-founder of Komodor. He’s a big believer in dev empowerment and moving fast, has worked at eBay, Forter and Rookout (as the founding engineer). Itiel is a backend and infra developer turned “DevOps”, an avid public speaker that loves talking about things such as cloud infrastructure, Kubernetes, Python, observability, and R&D culture.

In my experience, here are tips that can help you better adapt to using External DNS in Kubernetes:

Implement DNS caching:

Deploy local DNS caching within your cluster to reduce latency and minimize the number of external DNS lookups. Tools like CoreDNS can be configured for this purpose, improving performance for frequently accessed domains.

Use health checks for DNS records:

Configure health checks for your DNS records to automatically detect and remove unhealthy endpoints. This can prevent traffic from being routed to unavailable services and improve overall application availability.

Leverage DNS failover:

Set up DNS failover mechanisms to automatically redirect traffic to backup endpoints in case of primary service failures. This adds an additional layer of resilience and ensures continuous availability.

Adopt a hybrid DNS strategy:

Consider a hybrid approach by using both internal and external DNS. Internal DNS can handle intra-cluster traffic efficiently, while external DNS manages public-facing services. This setup optimizes performance and security.

Utilize multiple DNS providers

For critical applications, use multiple DNS providers to mitigate the risk of provider-specific outages. External DNS can be configured to update records across different providers, enhancing redundancy and reliability.

Benefits of External DNS in Kubernetes 

Granular Control

External DNS provides granular control over DNS records, even in complex multi-cluster environments. It allows for precise configuration of DNS entries based on the state of Kubernetes resources. This control ensures that DNS records accurately reflect the current deployment state, reducing the chances of misconfiguration and improving operational efficiency.

Granular control also increases the ability to tailor DNS configurations to meet specific requirements, such as custom routing policies or security rules. Additionally, it simplifies the management of domains and subdomains, providing a clear structure for organizing DNS resources.

Consistent DNS Infrastructure

With External DNS, organizations can maintain a consistent DNS infrastructure across multiple environments and cloud providers. This consistency is crucial for hybrid cloud deployments where services spread across on-premises and public cloud environments. External DNS centralizes DNS management, ensuring uniformity and reducing complexity.

Consistency also plays a crucial role in maintaining reliability and security across the infrastructure. By using a uniform DNS strategy, organizations can implement standardized policies, monitor DNS traffic effectively, and apply security measures consistently.

Scalability and Flexibility

External DNS provides scalability by allowing you to manage DNS entries for hundreds or thousands of domains efficiently. This is particularly beneficial as your Kubernetes deployment grows. It ensures that DNS management scales with your infrastructure, providing performance and reliability even at large scales.

Flexibility is another key advantage, as External DNS supports multiple DNS providers and can adapt to various deployment models.

Limitations of External DNS 

While External DNS offers many benefits, there are some limitations to consider:

Additional Complexity

Using External DNS introduces additional layers of complexity due to the need to manage and integrate third-party services. Configuration, monitoring, and troubleshooting of these external services require specialized knowledge and additional tooling. This complexity can increase the operational burden, especially in large and diverse environments.

The added components in the architecture may also introduce new points of failure. Dependencies on external services mean that any issue with the DNS provider can directly affect the availability and performance of your applications, necessitating robust monitoring and failover strategies.

Increased Costs

Deploying External DNS can lead to increased costs, as many DNS providers charge based on the number of DNS queries, records, and additional features like DDoS protection or geo-routing. These costs can accumulate quickly, especially in high-traffic environments. Proper budgeting and cost-monitoring practices are essential to manage expenses effectively.

Beyond direct costs, there’s also an indirect cost associated with the time and resources needed to manage and maintain external DNS integrations. Organizations must consider these expenses when evaluating the overall cost of using External DNS solutions.

Lack of Kubernetes-Specific Control

External DNS solutions may lack certain Kubernetes-specific controls, limiting the ability to finely tune DNS settings based on Kubernetes’ unique requirements. For instance, external providers may not fully support Kubernetes-native policies or annotations, which can hinder full integration and nuanced configuration.

This limitation can be particularly challenging in environments with complex networking needs or advanced security policies. Ensuring that the DNS provider closely aligns with Kubernetes capabilities is crucial but not always possible with external services.

Best Practices for Using External DNS with Kubernetes 

To maximize the effectiveness of External DNS in Kubernetes, adhere to the following best practices:

Ensure the DNS Provider Integrates Seamlessly with Kubernetes

Providers like AWS Route 53, Google Cloud DNS, and Azure DNS have solid track records of Kubernetes compatibility and robust API support.

A seamless integration enhances the operational efficiency of DNS updates and ensures minimal delays or failures. It also simplifies deployment and ongoing management, allowing your teams to focus on scaling and optimizing your Kubernetes environment.

Apply RBAC Policies to Limit ExternalDNS Permissions

Implement Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) policies to restrict ExternalDNS permissions to only necessary actions. By limiting permissions, you reduce the potential attack surface if the ExternalDNS instance is compromised.

RBAC policies also help ensure compliance with security best practices by enforcing the principle of least privilege. This approach minimizes risks associated with unauthorized access or modifications to DNS records, protecting the integrity of your DNS management.

Use Separate DNS Zones for Different Environments

Separate DNS zones should be used for different environments (e.g., development, staging, production) to isolate DNS management and prevent accidental overwrites or conflicts. By segmenting DNS zones, you ensure that changes in one environment do not impact another, providing clearly defined boundaries.

Separate DNS zones also aid in implementing environment-specific policies, such as varying TTL values or custom DNS rules. This separation enhances the manageability and security of your DNS infrastructure.

Configure Appropriate Time-To-Live (TTL) Values for Your DNS Records

Configure appropriate Time-To-Live (TTL) values for DNS records to balance between performance and resource utilization. Shorter TTL values ensure faster propagation of changes but can increase query load on your DNS servers. Conversely, longer TTLs reduce the query load but may delay the propagation of updates.

Finding the right balance involves considering the specific needs of your applications and the behavior of your DNS provider. Regularly reviewing and adjusting TTL values based on real-world usage can optimize DNS performance and reliability.

Utilize Kubernetes DNS Policies to Customize DNS Resolution Behavior for Pods

Kubernetes DNS policies can be used to customize DNS resolution behavior for Pods, allowing fine-grained control over DNS lookups. By applying these policies, you can route DNS queries differently based on the namespace, pod labels, or other attributes.

Custom DNS resolution behavior is beneficial for meeting specific application requirements, such as local caching or splitting DNS traffic across multiple endpoints. It enhances the overall DNS architecture, providing flexibility and performance improvements tailored to your workloads.

Monitor DNS Queries and Responses to Detect and Resolve Issues Promptly

Consistent monitoring of DNS queries and responses is critical for detecting and resolving issues rapidly. Implement monitoring tools that provide real-time insights into DNS traffic, alerting you to anomalies or performance bottlenecks.

Monitoring also aids in identifying unused or stale DNS records and optimizing DNS settings based on observed traffic patterns. Proactive monitoring helps maintain high availability and performance of your DNS infrastructure, ensuring that end users experience minimal disruptions.

Simplifying Kubernetes Management with Komodor

Komodor is the Continuous Kubernetes Reliability Platform, designed to democratize K8s expertise across the organization and enable engineering teams to leverage its full value.

Komodor’s platform empowers developers to confidently monitor and troubleshoot their workloads while allowing cluster operators to enforce standardization and optimize performance. Specifically when working in a hybrid environment, Komodor reduces the complexity by providing a unified view of all your services and clusters.

By leveraging Komodor, companies of all sizes significantly improve reliability, productivity, and velocity. Or, to put it simply – Komodor helps you spend less time and resources on managing Kubernetes, and more time on innovating at scale.
If you are interested in checking out Komodor, use this link to sign up for a Free Trial.